“Sub City New York”
Sub City New York from Redglass Pictures on Vimeo.
I first heard Erik Satie’s “Gymnopédies” in Man On Wire, a documentary made about Philippe Petit. In 1974, Petit rigged a wire across the two World Trade Center towers and walked across it, irritating NYC law enforcement and bewildering bystanders below. It was the perfect piece of music for the documentary—everything about the slow, vaguely melancholy piano seemed to belong in and to the film. Technically, Gymnopédies is a three-part piano composition, but that’s besides the point. What it is, quite simply, is beautiful.
Shortly after watching Man On Wire, Gymnopédies surfaced again, this time in an entirely different work of art: a short film by Sarah Klein and Tom Mason of Redglass Pictures. In this dreamy ode to urban life, the filmmakers give weight and acknowledgement to a mundane activity like riding the subway using visuals and music. Although short, the piece has real resonance because of the filmmakers’ ability to capture the tiny beauties of daily existence, like that first batch of sunlight you see when emerging from the subway, or the brief flashes of interaction you have as you meet the eyes of those around you. All of that is really quite intense, but perhaps what seals the deal in terms of emotional resonance is the use of Gymnopédies in Sarah and Tom’s piece. In the same way that the track seemed to fit perfectly in Man On Wire, it also seems to complement Sub City New York so very well—almost as if it were a custom track. What’s really interesting to me is that even though Man On Wire and Sub City New York are two entirely different pieces, they both benefit greatly from the use of the very same song. Why is that?
Enter, the appoggiatura
In the raging din of the world around us, it’s simply magical when you discover a song—any song—that truly moves you. When it moves millions of other people, too, it becomes news. So it’s not entirely surprising that just before Valentine’s Day, the Wall Street Journal ran an article about Grammy winning musician, Adele, and the power her music has to impact so many emotionally. In the article, they argued that people found her music emotionally compelling because of what’s known as the “appoggiatura,” a type of note that injects just the right bit of tension into a song, causing a reaction in the listener. When the appoggiatura occurs again and again, it only amplifies the effect it has on the listener. Bolstered by real research completed by psychologist John Sloboda and more recently, Martin Guhn, it seems that the appoggiatura is a certifiable emotional catalyst in many popular songs.
I’m not educated well enough in music to know if this same technique is used in Gymnopédies, or what its counterpoint here would even be called, but it’s interesting nonetheless to discover the way music has the power to create a very real response in the listener, conveying in a permanent way the often fleeting (yet, arguably, important) moments of life.
Post script: Philippe Petit and his story also ended up in a great book, Let the Great World Spin, written by Colum McCann and available on Amazon.